FNILX vs. SPY: Which is Better?
FNILX and SPY are both diversified large-cap investment funds, but there are several differences, including:
SPY is an ETF, while FNILX is a mutual fund
FNILX has no expense ratio, while SPY’s is 0.09%
FNILX only pays a dividend once per year
SPY is tradeable for active traders
FNILX tracks the Fidelity Large-Cap Index
SPY tracks the S&P 500 Index
Key Characteristics and Differences
Both FNILX and SPY invest in large cap, leaning toward blend investments, implying a mix of growth and value stocks. FNILX, offered by Fidelity, is a mutual fund, while SPY, managed by State Street Global Advisors, is an ETF tracking the S&P 500.
Because of their inherent natures, FNILX requires a minimum investment, typically for a set number of shares, commonly known as the mutual fund’s share price, while SPY allows you to purchase just one share of the ETF. It’s vital this elemental understanding forms the basis of your decision-making process.
Performance Analysis: FNILX vs. SPY
FNILX and SPY performances generally mirror each other, as they both track large-cap U.S. stocks.
However, over certain periods, FNILX may lag behind SPY. This is due to FNILX having a slightly wider investment universe, including some stocks not in the S&P 500, which may underperform the market at times.
On the flip side, FNILX can potentially outperform SPY during periods when these additional stocks perform better than the S&P 500. These subtle performance differences stem from broader-than-SP-500 coverage - a characteristic of FNILX.
Dividend Comparison: FNILX vs. SPY
Both FNILX and SPY pay nearly identical dividend yields. However, FNILX only pays dividends once per year to account for the lack of expense ratio.
SPY, being an ETF, typically pays out dividends directly to shareholders. They declare dividends on a quarterly basis.
On the other hand, FNILX, being a mutual fund, might automatically reinvest dividends, providing a compound interest effect bolstering your investment’s value over time - a critical consideration for long-term investors.
Expense Ratio Analysis: FNILX vs. SPY
Regarding expense ratios, FNILX is a clear winner as it has an expense ratio of 0.00%, living up to Fidelity’s ZERO name. Meanwhile, SPY charges a modest expense ratio of 0.09%.
While this is relatively low for an ETF, over the long term, it could eat into your investment returns relative to FNILX and might be something to consider, especially for the more cost-conscious investor.
Risk-Adjusted Performance: FNILX vs. SPY
Risk-adjusted performance, commonly measured for the funds, takes into account the level of risk involved in achieving returns. A high-risk strategy might generate significant returns, but quieter market periods or downturns can drastically affect the fund’s performance.
Comparatively, both FNILX and SPY offer inherent risk due to their exposure to equities but balance that with the stability and consistency of a broad-based approach.
Volatility Comparison: FNILX vs. SPY
Looking at volatility, both FNILX and SPY should exhibit similar levels in line with the broader market.
This is due to their closely aligned investment targets, although, as previously mentioned, FNILX has a slightly broader selection pool than SPY.
Investment Strategy and Holdings
FNILX aims to replicate the performance of large-capitalization U.S. stocks, owning a diverse basket of more than 500 U.S. companies across multiple industries.
On the other hand, SPY adopts a passive management approach, directly tracking the S&P 500 index.
Both strategies offer broad diversification across different sectors, minimizing the downside risk associated with exposure to any single company.
Choosing the Right Index Fund: FNILX or SPY
With the comprehensive breakdown above, the ultimate choice between FNILX and SPY boils down to your individual needs and investment strategy. If your objective is tighter tracking, trading flexibility, and direct dividends, SPY aligns with your goals.
However, if you’re angling towards a cost-efficient, auto-compounding, and broader large-cap exposure investment, FNILX is your go-to fund. Zero expense ratio, dividend reinvestment, and a slightly wider investment mandate could potentially lead to higher returns in the long run.
If you want to learn more about investing in the stock market, you can join the HaiKhuu Trading Community.
HaiKhuu offers live trading calls, daily morning reports, and an awesome community of like-minded traders to learn from.
FAQ
Is FNILX better than the S&P 500?
FNILX aims to provide results consistent with the overall performance of U.S. large capitalization stocks. On the other hand, SPY directly tracks the S&P 500 index, making SPY a more direct method of investing in the general market performance. The “better” choice depends on individual investing styles and portfolios.
Is FNILX a good investment?
As an index fund, FNILX is designed for investors who desire exposure to U.S. large-cap stocks without having to analyze and select individual companies. With its no-fee structure, FNILX is a cost-efficient choice for those who prioritize minimizing expenses, providing an attractive option for passive investors.
